skip to main content
HAPPY EARTH DAY! GET 15% OFF YOUR ORDER
  • Quick Reorder
  • Promo Pocket
  • Email Sign Up
  • Deliver to 43085

    Update your location

    Availability of products may vary by location.

    Shipping to:




Category
Featured Items
Brand
Price
Rating
Specialties
Form
Servings
Flavor
Availability

Sugar Substitutes

Sorry, the product you're searching for is no longer available.
Based on your search, our Product Specialists suggest the following items:

Showing Products 1-60 of 186
Sort By
Go Go
    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract

    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract -- 4 fl oz

    (959)

    $9.89

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Organic Maple Syrup Grade A Dark Color

    Simple Truth Organic Maple Syrup Grade A Dark Color -- 32 fl oz

    (79)

    $17.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Allulose Sugar Substitute

    Simple Truth Allulose Sugar Substitute -- 12 oz

    (19)

    $6.99

    $0.19 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Non-GMO Liquid Steviaclear Sweet Drops Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Non-GMO Liquid Steviaclear Sweet Drops Sweetener -- 4 fl oz

    (178)

    $14.49

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods Better Stevia Organic Liquid Sweetener

    NOW Foods Better Stevia Organic Liquid Sweetener -- 8 fl oz

    (194)

    $21.29

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Sweetener -- 70 Packets

    (72)

    $7.79

    $0.06 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Vanilla

    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Vanilla -- 2 fl oz

    (107)

    $8.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener English Toffee

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener English Toffee -- 2 fl oz

    (98)

    $9.79

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Caramel

    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Caramel -- 2 fl oz

    (118)

    $8.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Non-GMO Stevia Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Non-GMO Stevia Sweetener -- 4 oz

    (144)

    $9.19

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener French Vanilla

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener French Vanilla -- 2 fl oz

    (108)

    $9.59

    $0.02 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Stevia Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Stevia Sweetener -- 70 Packets

    (197)

    $7.09

    $0.06 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Glycerite Alcohol Free Liquid Extract

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Glycerite Alcohol Free Liquid Extract -- 8 fl oz

    (102)

    $19.59

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener Vanilla Creme

    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener Vanilla Creme -- 2 fl oz

    (430)

    $10.89

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener English Toffee

    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener English Toffee -- 2 fl oz

    (132)

    $9.79

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Stevita Naturals Organic Original Stevia Sweetener

    Stevita Naturals Organic Original Stevia Sweetener -- 16 oz

    (209)

    $30.29

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code ALLSTEVITA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Monk Fruit Sweetener Drops Original

    Lakanto Monk Fruit Sweetener Drops Original -- 1.76 fl oz

    (222)

    $12.49

    $0.05 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Organic Stevia Extract Blend

    Simple Truth Organic Stevia Extract Blend -- 40 Packets

    (20)

    $3.19

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Original

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Original -- 8 fl oz

    (83)

    $19.09

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods Organic Monk Fruit Zero Calorie Sweetener

    NOW Foods Organic Monk Fruit Zero Calorie Sweetener -- 2 fl oz

    (59)

    $10.49

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods Xylitol

    NOW Foods Xylitol -- 1 lb

    (44)

    $7.59

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Organic Zero Calorie Powdered Sweetener

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Organic Zero Calorie Powdered Sweetener -- 1 oz

    (120)

    $7.59

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Organic Zero Calorie Powdered Sweetener

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Organic Zero Calorie Powdered Sweetener -- 4 oz

    (92)

    $21.09

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Whole Earth Stevia Leaf & Monk Fruit Plant-Based Sweetener Spoonable

    Whole Earth Stevia Leaf & Monk Fruit Plant-Based Sweetener Spoonable -- 9.8 oz

    (1)

    $7.19

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NuNaturals Non-GMO NuStevia Syrup Cocoa

    NuNaturals Non-GMO NuStevia Syrup Cocoa -- 16 fl oz

    (119)

    $16.69

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Sweetener -- 3.2 oz

    (36)

    $10.69

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NuNaturals Non-GMO White Stevia Powder

    NuNaturals Non-GMO White Stevia Powder -- 12 oz

    (88)

    $18.69

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair-Trade Stevia Drops

    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair-Trade Stevia Drops -- 100 mL - 3.3 oz

    (110)

    $16.09

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code ALLSTEVITA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Dark Chocolate

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Dark Chocolate -- 2 fl oz

    (56)

    $8.69

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods Slender Zero Organic Allulose Powder

    NOW Foods Slender Zero Organic Allulose Powder -- 12 oz

    (3)

    $10.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair Trade Stevia Drops

    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair Trade Stevia Drops -- 1.35 fl oz

    (93)

    $8.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code ALLSTEVITA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Monk Fruit Granular Organic Sweetener

    SweetLeaf Monk Fruit Granular Organic Sweetener -- 28.2 oz

    (10)

    $14.19

    $0.08 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Madhava Organic Amber 100% Raw Blue Agave

    Madhava Organic Amber 100% Raw Blue Agave -- 46 oz

    (88)

    $16.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code 20MADHAVA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Liquid Monkfruit Extract Drops Vanilla

    Lakanto Liquid Monkfruit Extract Drops Vanilla -- 1.76 fl oz

    (200)

    $10.82

    $0.05 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NuNaturals Non-GMO White Stevia Powder

    NuNaturals Non-GMO White Stevia Powder -- 100 Packets

    (81)

    $7.79

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NuNaturals Non-GMO Clear Extract Stevia

    NuNaturals Non-GMO Clear Extract Stevia -- 2 fl oz

    (58)

    $11.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Leaf Extract

    SweetLeaf Organic Stevia Leaf Extract -- 0.9 oz

    (116)

    $13.49

    $0.02 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Organic Liquid Monk Fruit

    NOW Organic Liquid Monk Fruit -- 8 fl oz

    (16)

    $32.79

    $0.13 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetener

    Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetener -- 30 Packs

    (37)

    $5.64

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    KAL Sure Stevia Extract

    KAL Sure Stevia Extract -- 3.5 oz

    (284)

    $34.47

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code KAL25 to save 25%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Non-GMO Foods Xylitol

    NOW Non-GMO Foods Xylitol -- 2.5 lbs

    (66)

    $16.89

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Organic Blue Agave Light Golden Syrup

    Simple Truth Organic Blue Agave Light Golden Syrup -- 23.5 oz

    (8)

    $6.29

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Wholesome Allulose

    Wholesome Allulose -- 11.5 oz

    (5)

    $6.89

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code WHOLESOME20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Stevita Naturals Organic Stevia

    Stevita Naturals Organic Stevia -- 50 Packets

    (51)

    $6.74

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code ALLSTEVITA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener Chocolate

    SweetLeaf Sweet Drops Sweetener Chocolate -- 2 fl oz

    (172)

    $10.79

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair Trade Stevia Extra Sweet

    Stevita Naturals Organic Fair Trade Stevia Extra Sweet -- 0.7 oz

    (66)

    $22.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code ALLSTEVITA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Wholesome Organic Stevia

    Wholesome Organic Stevia -- 75 Packets

    (45)

    $5.89

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code WHOLESOME20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Vitacost Gluten Free Non-GMO Stevia Calorie Free Sweetener Blend

    Vitacost Gluten Free Non-GMO Stevia Calorie Free Sweetener Blend -- 100 Packets

    (57)

    $6.73

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Chocolate

    Vitacost Liquid Stevia Extract Natural Chocolate -- 2 fl oz

    (35)

    $9.99

    $0.04 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Zero Calorie Sweetener Original

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Zero Calorie Sweetener Original -- 100 Packets

    (17)

    $7.09

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods Organic Monk Fruit Extract Powder

    NOW Foods Organic Monk Fruit Extract Powder -- 0.7 oz

    (18)

    $25.29

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Monk Fruit Sweetener - Golden

    Lakanto Monk Fruit Sweetener - Golden -- 28.22 oz

    (378)

    $16.96

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Coconut

    NOW Foods BetterStevia Liquid Sweetener Coconut -- 2 fl oz

    (52)

    $10.99

    $0.03 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Madhava Organic Agave Five

    Madhava Organic Agave Five -- 16 oz

    (15)

    $5.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code 20MADHAVA to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    NOW BetterStevia Liquid Maple

    NOW BetterStevia Liquid Maple -- 2 fl oz

    (1)

    $8.19

    $0.05 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code NOW20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Classic Monkfruit Sweetener

    Lakanto Classic Monkfruit Sweetener -- 1 lb

    (685)

    $10.72

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Wholesome Allulose Granulated

    Wholesome Allulose Granulated -- 12 oz

    (2)

    $10.99

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code WHOLESOME20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Swerve Brown

    Swerve Brown -- 12 oz

    $7.69

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetener Classic

    Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetener Classic -- 28.22 oz

    (666)

    $17.78

    $0.18 per serving

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Wholesome Organic Raw Blue Agave

    Wholesome Organic Raw Blue Agave -- 44 fl oz

    (53)

    $13.29

    • Use code EARTHDAY to save 15%
    • Use code WHOLESOME20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
Sign Up & Save

Get exclusive offers, free shipping events, expert health tips & more by signing up for our promotional emails.

USA Today Americas Customer Service Champions 20204

Copyright © 2025 Vitacost.com. All rights reserved • Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.

Please enter a valid zip code
FLDC15